You can’t go wrong buying either Bobcat or Caterpillar for accomplishing farming and construction of heavy-lifting tasks. Both brands introduced a wide range of machinery for various heavy-duty jobs. But when buying a new excavator, you must know the difference between them. So, between Bobcat and Caterpillar – which one is the best?
Caterpillar engines are tough enough to handle the most heavy-duty task with 11 – 2,000 HP. While the Bobcat engine’s HP range is 21 to 58 HP. Moreover, the average lifespan for Bobcat machines is 10,000 – 12,000 hours. Caterpillar excavators can provide service for up to 20,000 hours when proper maintenance is ensured.
They have some similarities as well. Don’t skip anything until you finish reading this guide on Bobcat vs. Caterpillar.
Bobcat vs. Caterpillar – Comparison Chart
Need help in making a buying decision between Caterpillar and Bobcat? Here is a comparison of the key features at a glance.
| Parameter | Bobcat | Caterpillar |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Doosan Group | MacAllister Machinery |
| Engine Power | 21 to 105 HP | 11 – 2,000 HP |
| Lifespan | 10,000 – 12,000 hours | 15,000 – 20,000 hours |
| Seat Adjustability | Yes | Yes |
| Overall Comfort | Comfortable | Comfortable |
| Overall Efficiency | Highly Efficient | Highly Efficient |
| Handling Ability | Straightforward | Straightforward |
| Price Range | $60,000 to $100,000 | $100,000 to $230,000 |
| Maintenance Cost | $500-$1,000 | $500-$1,000 |
Caterpillar vs Bobcat – In-depth Discussion of the Comparisons
While preparing the differences, I closely examine the features, benefits, and drawbacks of different Cat and Bobcat excavator models. I prepared this section based on my research. Read the differences intently.
Engine Power
Caterpillar machines are powerful for their robust construction. This company manufactures the C32 V12 model equipped with the most powerful engine having 2,000 HP @ 2,300 RPM. The maximum torque is 5,532 lb-ft @ 1,300 – 1,800 RPM.
Bobcat machines are less powerful than its competitor Caterpillar. The top-rated power of the Bobcat machine is 105 HP. The best thing about Bobcats is they are compact and lightweight. As a result, Bobcats can handle heavy-duty jobs in tight spaces quite easily. They are suitable for excavation, landscaping, or other smaller-scale tasks.
Both companies offer the machine with outstanding performance. You will need to choose the one that meets your project requirements.
Lifespan
Bobcat and caterpillar machines have been designed to provide service for several years. They are subjected to periodic maintenance and provide up to 15,000 hours of efficient service. You will barely find other excavators providing service for such long hours.
However, to get long-term service from Bobcat and Caterpillar, periodic maintenance is a must. When the manufacturer’s maintenance schedule is maintained, Caterpillar provides 20,000 hours of service. For Bobcat, the service hours increase to 15,000.
In a nutshell, both companies make reliable machines. Efficient and long-term performance depends on the user.
Overall Comfort
I looked at the specifications and features of different models made by Bobcat and Caterpillar.
In Bobcat machines, you will be impressed with the comfortability features. To ensure excellent comfort, they are designed with smooth suspension seats. The seat is responsible for absorbing vibrations of bumps and bad road conditions. Moreover, the engines don’t create much sound, meaning you will always have a comfortable ride.
Caterpillar machines are also built with comfortability in mind. The workstation, controls, and operator station are close to the driver. As a result, you will never face the hassle of driving them in different road conditions.
Overall Efficiency
The Doosan Group and MacAllister Inc. manufacture Bobcat and Caterpillar machines, respectively. Both manufacturers have years of experience in the field.
They did lots of research and development in their machines throughout the journey. They aim to provide the best efficient machine to customers. The good news is they achieved the reputation of manufacturing the industry’s finest and most efficient engines.
In reality, a few companies are able to match the efficiency and reputation of Doosan and MacAllister.
Price Range
Price is always a crucial factor when buying an excavator.
Generally, Caterpillar models are expensive compared to Bobcat. For a brand-new Caterpillar, you must spend $100,000 – $230,000. In fact, Cat machines offer top-class longevity, value, performance, and after-service support. Bear in mind you will get what you pay.
Whereas, Bobcats are pretty inexpensive. Don’t assume that they are poor in performance. Bobcat machines are the best contender for Caterpillars. The price range of Bobcat machines is $60,000 – $100,000. Their products are suitable for those who are on a budget.
Maintenance Cost
Consider maintenance costs as well when purchasing Bobcat or Caterpillar. Usually, the maintenance cost for both brands is similar.
The range for maintenance cost is $500-$1,000. Keep in mind this cost is for periodic maintenance and oil change. However, it can be more based on the model and level of damage.
Parts are relatively costlier for both brands. The reason is excavators from these companies are of premium quality. But the price may vary as per the machine’s model and make.
It is advisable to ensure periodic maintenance, which will help you avoid costly repairs. More importantly, regular maintenance will ensure the longevity of the machines.
Reliability
When researching, I found that Cat customers are more satisfied with their machine’s performance. Cat machines are full-efficient and offer high performance.
On the other hand, Bobcat owners experienced different problems with their excavators or skid steers. Thankfully, these problems are easy to handle, and spare parts are available.
Here you will have to understand that no machines are perfect. Moreover, the key to getting reliable performance is proper maintenance. Both brands deliver reliable performance for long periods when periodic maintenance is guaranteed.
Both brands have a strong presence in the market, which says everything.
Customer Support
Aftercare support and customer service are great for both Bobcat and Caterpillar. Customers can effortlessly contact the manufacturers with their queries about the machines.
Cat offers 24/7 customer support. They have skilled technical experts and damn trained technicians to help the customers with faster solutions to any problems related to the machines.
Bobcat customer service is also worth mentioning. They provide telephone assistance, online tools for troubleshooting, and in-person maintenance service when needed. Also, they have educational resources and videos so users can use the machine properly for ultimate performance.
Providing an excellent level of customer support is a promise of both companies.
Bobcat vs. Caterpillar – Which One to Buy?
It is hard to declare a winner in this race. Both brands have their own set of unique features, pros, and cons. You have to buy according to your project needs.
Buy Caterpillar, if
- You are looking for a robust machine to handle the toughest jobs
- Your preference is high-engine power
Buy Bobcat, if
- You need a compact and lightweight machine to tackle tasks in tight spaces
- Your budget is low while seeking an efficient excavator
Final Words
Despite the difference between Bobcat vs. Caterpillar, it is clear why both brands are reliable names in the market. Whether you choose Cat or Bobcat, you will get what you need from both companies.
Now, the ball is in your court. Set your needs and look at the certain models that meet your requirements. Finally, make a move. I can guarantee you will always be satisfied selecting any of them.
Video References
Stanley “Dirt Monkey” Genadek
Meet Emily, a true garden lover who has a passion for all things nature. With a deep understanding of plants and lawns, Emily’s love for gardening started at a young age, spending her summers tending to her grandparents’ garden.